I've designed two different versions of the logo, one light-on-dark, and one dark-on-light:

I designed these to fit within 8x8 tiles comfortably, so we could even use them to spruce up the game selection screen of future volumes of A53.
vol.3 as an example since I had the ROM easily available:

With this layout, we can fit up to three awards along the bottom of the screen, which would be necessary for Project Blue…
Using a copy of the judging spreadsheet, I ran the weighted total calculation on each category, resulting in the following:
Gruniożerca 2: 1st Place; Most Polished
Project Blue: 2nd Place; Best Graphics; Best Sound
Wolfling: 3rd Place
The Alfonzo Game: 4th Place
Miedow (Cheril's Nightmares): 5th Place
Star Evil: Most Original
…and I've got logos for all of the competition years ready to go; if we have access to the raw judging data to determine them, we can retroactively declare these achievements.
Also, I can pull quick vector conversions of these for each year, so we can make the resources available to whomeve would benefit from them (developers making box art, reviewers, etc.)
…oh, and if we want to go with "Art and Style" instead of "Graphics" (to coincide with judging categories) we can:

Thoughts?